Writing Critique Groups

Writing is a solitary art. Generally, we spend time alone at the keyboard trying to put on paper what’s so easily flowing through our minds. However, it’s important to involve others in your writing in the form of a critique group.Critique groups can offer you insight into your writing. It’s difficult to objectively view your own work. When you allow others to read it, they can point out weaknesses as well as strengths. An honest critique is one the most valuable tools a writer can have. Writers should always have others read-through their manuscript before submitting it to a publisher.

Here are some things to consider when searching for a critique group:

Ease of Use Can you attend meetings in person or do you need an online group? Are you willing to travel to attend meetings? Will attending this critique group be too difficult? Do you need to meet at night, during the day, or on weekends? Look for a group that best suits your schedule and allows you the most interaction with the members.

Skills of Members Try to find a group with members whose skills are closest to your own. Usually having at least one member who has been published is ideal.The more experience members have, the better. However, all writers are beginners at some point and there’s nothing wrong with forming a critique group with new writers.

Critiques How will the members deliver comments?  It’s a good idea to establish rules for the members to follow so everyone understands how to critique. A great rule of thumb for critiquing is the sandwich method. Mention the strengths of the work first, followed by what can be improved, and ending with a positive message.

When you critique someone else’s work it’s important to give honest feedback, but in a diplomatic way. Shredding someone’s work and telling her it’s atrocious won’t help her improve nor will it endear you to her. Make constructive comments in such a way that they aren’t offensive. “I might stay away from a flashback right here because it feels confusing,” is different from, “Flashbacks are ridiculous and your writing is so confusing I had to quit reading it.”

Critique groups can offer you the help you need to make your manuscript publishable. Remember to always reciprocate and be willing to read others’ work. Effective critique groups work to help all its members succeed.